Jag är lite skeptisk till detta påstående. Kanske felaktigt och av okunnighet. Jag måste därför fråga vad detta "hantverkskunnande" består av lite mer konkret.
//F
Jag sysslar inte alls med att generera bilder med promptning men däremot har jag jobbat rätt mycket och rätt hårt för att få AI att tolka mina bilder och skapa bildbeskrivningar och de sökord jag vill ha. Styr man inte det blir det inte alls som man vill ha det. Det är dessutom så att olika AI-modeller har egna egenheter och därför måste denna prompning även i viss mån anpassas till de olika egenskaperna de olika modellerna har.
Dels handlar det dessutom att förhindra att AI skriver sånt som INTE finns i bilderna och om hur texterna formateras.
Man måste också ta höjd för hur olika typer av motiv hanteras av de olika modellerna.
Först nedan så ser ni hur dessa promptar ser ut och sedan följer 2 exempel på AI-genererade texter med olika motiv.
Jag kan faktiskt tänka mig att det är ännu mer komplicerat att få det som, man vill i detalj om man vill styra hur generativ AI skapar en bild. Det många fotografer verkar ha svårt att ta till sig att deras yrke till stor del nu kommer ersättas av helt nya yrkesgrupper som nu kan ta fram bilder och illustrationer med hjälp av förlagor (som kan vara fotografier) ofta på en bråkdel av den tid det tar för hela den process det idag kan ta en beställare och en eller flera fotografer att leverera.
Nu ersätts många av fotograferna på samma sätt som fotograferna ersatte målare och xylografer i slutet på 1800-talet som tidigare illustrerade exv. tidningar m.m. Då förfasade sig säkert xylograferna innan de snabbt blev utkonkurrerade av fotograferna som då var en ny yrkesgrupp på marknaden.
I mitt IMatch DAM så finns fyra olika promptar varav tre är relativt statiska:
Descriptions
Keywords
Landmarks
Dessutom finns en
Ad-Hoc-prompt som man hanterar det som är speciellt för ett särskilt urval av bilder. I mitt fall få brukar jag alltid lägga en obligatorisk första rad med platsinfo och när en bild är tagen:
Nedan kan du se hur mycket det faktiskt står i dessa:
Descriptions:
[[-c-]]
General instruction:
Always priority for geografic data in the first line and than add a space, the year the picture is taken and peoples names.
{File.Persons.Label.Confirmed|hasvalue:These persons are shown in this image: {File.Persons.Label.Confirmed}.}
Always translate and write texts on signs into English.
Describe picture in a factual, rich, casual and vivid style.
Use simple English, common words, factual language, and simple sentences.
Avoid describing anything not directly observable in the image.
Always write the Description in 3 paragraphs.
Return the names of known landmarks, historic buildings and tourist spots in this image and describe them {File.MD.description}
If it is a building identify it and where it is situated, when it was built and by which architecture.
What was it originally used for.
Separate paragraphs with a blank line (i.e., exactly two line breaks between paragraphs).
Do not use bullet lists.
Animal section:
If animals in picture , always provide a deep and factual zoological professional description of the animals appearance, habitat, diet, behaviors, and any unique characteristics.
Consider adding notable facts or interesting trivia about this species.
Also describe their most common distribution areas and whether, for example, there are different variants of the specie and their possible peculiarities.
It is mandatory to write in which areas of the world they most likely are to be found?
Always add space before
If there is an animal, flower or plant in the image, write the animal’s, flower's or plant's common name, family name, and scientific (Latin) name in the format below and always as the last three lines of text – after the space:
Common name: [Species common name]
Family: [Family name]
Scientific name: [Latin name]
Else never write anything you don´t see in the picture. Return nothing.
Don´t write any + signs
End with:
Line feed - space plus
Only write Architecture Type if there is Architecture present in the motif else don´t write anything
Architecture type or style: [Architecture type or style]
Keywords:
[[-c-]]
Never ever write hieracic Keywords with pipe characters like in Flowers|Grass
Maximum seven Keywords and never in plural form
Use simple English, common words, factual language.
Preferably just one ord in each keyword.
Never write name of places, country or year in keywords
No words with only capital letters
If there is an animal, flower or plant in the image, write the animal’s, flower's or plant's "Common name" in the Keywords
If there is an animal keywords with two words are allowed
If more than one specie write for all species in picture
If it is a Mammal write Animal and Mammal
If it is a Bird write Animal and Bird
If it is a Reptile write Animal and Reptile
If it is a Fish write Animal and Fish
If it is an Insect write Animal and Insect
If it is a Flower write Flower
If it is a Tree write Tree
If it is a Plant write Plant
If it is a Fruit write Fruit
If it is a Vehicle write type of Vehicle
Else never write anything. Return nothing.
Landmarks:
[[-c-]]
Identify the exact name of the landmark,
monument, or architectural structure in the image.
Include who is the architect
Include the specific city and country.
If a specific part of a building is shown (e.g., 'Nativity Façade'), include that detail.
Respond with the name and location, for example: 'Sagrada Família, Barcelona, Spain'.
Perform a deep visual analysis of the architectural elements present.
Identify specific patterns, ornaments, or structural features unique to famous global landmarks.
Based on these visual cues, provide your most accurate identification of the site and justify your reasoning by mentioning the specific stylistic markers you detected
If you also have possibility to describe importat pieces of the interior it is appreciated.
If you cannot detect any landmarks or tourist spots:
Never write "No specific landmark can be identified"
Just abort
Exempel 1 Ad Hoc-prompt Arkitekturbild
no reasoning
no speculation
Translate text and signs to English
Mandatory text only to write on the first line of Descriptions: Paris France 2017 -
AI-Genererad text:
Paris France 2017 - Cour d’Honneur of the Palais de Justice, Paris, France.
This is the grand Cour d’Honneur of the Palais de Justice on the Île de la Cité in Paris. The complex is a monumental example of French classical and Beaux-Arts architecture, blending symmetry, grand columns, and rich ornamental details. The central pavilion with its large dome and pedimented section reflects the formal, ceremonial style typical of Parisian state buildings.
The façade features tall Corinthian columns, evenly spaced window bays, and a slate mansard roof with dormers, all hallmarks of the Beaux-Arts tradition. The ornate wrought-iron gate, adorned with gold scrolling and a gilded crest, adds a sense of grandeur and authority. The courtyard’s open square and axial layout emphasize the building’s role as a historic justice complex, housing major courts for centuries.
The Palais de Justice was originally part of the medieval royal palace and later expanded to serve as the seat of France’s judicial system. Designed by architects like Louis Lenormand and Joseph-Louis Duc, it embodies the 19th-century revival of classical forms, prioritizing grand civic composition and rich decorative elements. The site remains a key landmark in Paris, symbolizing the intersection of history, law, and architecture.
Common name: French classical and Beaux-Arts
Architecture type or style: French classical and Beaux-Arts
This is the grand Cour d’Honneur of the Palais de Justice on the Île de la Cité in Paris. The complex is a monumental example of French classical and Beaux-Arts architecture, blending symmetry, grand columns, and rich ornamental details. The central pavilion with its large dome and pedimented section reflects the formal, ceremonial style typical of Parisian state buildings.
The façade features tall Corinthian columns, evenly spaced window bays, and a slate mansard roof with dormers, all hallmarks of the Beaux-Arts tradition. The ornate wrought-iron gate, adorned with gold scrolling and a gilded crest, adds a sense of grandeur and authority. The courtyard’s open square and axial layout emphasize the building’s role as a historic justice complex, housing major courts for centuries.
The Palais de Justice was originally part of the medieval royal palace and later expanded to serve as the seat of France’s judicial system. Designed by architects like Louis Lenormand and Joseph-Louis Duc, it embodies the 19th-century revival of classical forms, prioritizing grand civic composition and rich decorative elements. The site remains a key landmark in Paris, symbolizing the intersection of history, law, and architecture.
Common name: French classical and Beaux-Arts
Architecture type or style: French classical and Beaux-Arts
stenisfoto.imagedesk.se
